Soups & Shakes for Type 2 Diabetes
Please login to view this content
The big news in the UK last week was “Thousands to benefit from soups and shakes diet on the NHS from today” (Ref 1). The National Health Service (NHS) web site proudly announced, "From today thousands of people will be able to access NHS soup and shake weight-loss plans to tackle type 2 diabetes." It continued: "The diet and lifestyle plans have been shown to put Type 2 diabetes into remission for people recently diagnosed with the condition, and will now be provided to 5,000 more patients in 10 areas as the first stage in an NHS drive to increase access to the life-changing programme." (The 10 areas involved in the first stage are listed on the web page referenced).
The numbers were sobering: "Diabetes is estimated to cost the NHS £10 billion a year, while almost one in 20 prescriptions written by GPs is for diabetes treatment."
Some detail was provided – the “year-long plans” would provide total diet replacement products (soups and shakes) for three months, alongside support to increase exercise levels. Thereafter there would be ongoing support from clinicians and coaches to reintroduce “ordinary, nutritious food.”
No reference was given to provide evidence for the initiative, but the announcement said, “Results from one trial showed almost half of those who went on the diet achieved remission of their Type 2 diabetes after one year.” That’s the Professor Roy Taylor Newcastle DiRECT study, therefore (DIabetes REmission Clinical Trial).
I covered the DiRECT study when the seminal paper was published in December 2017 (Ref 2). The DiRECT study presented itself as "the first evidence from a randomised trial of a dietary and lifestyle intervention with remission of type 2 diabetes as a primary outcome." This was false from the outset, as Dr Eric Westman et al published a randomised controlled dietary trial (low carbohydrate intervention) in 84 people with type 2 diabetes in 2008. The primary outcome was the same measure of diabetes remission as the DiRECT study – HbA1c and medication reduction/elimination. The 2008 paper used the word “reversing”, rather than remission, but the outcome was achieved (Ref 3).
In that post I presented the evidence at that time for the three proven ways in which to put type 2 diabetes (T2D) into remission: bariatric surgery; very low calorie diets; and (very) low carbohydrate diets. Evidence for bariatric surgery dated back to 2004 and Professor Roy Taylor himself wrote a paper in 2008 noting the impact of bariatric surgery on T2D. Evidence for very low calorie interventions dated back as far as 1976 and Westman’s was the first key paper presenting the case for low carb diets (Ref 4).
It's been over two and a half years since we last looked at the DiRECT study and further papers have been published since, so let’s revisit it.
The rest of this article is available to site members, who get access to all articles plus a weekly newsletter.
To continue reading, please login below or sign up for a membership. Thank you.