Conflicted nutritionists defend bread

Not a grain of truth: Bread has been ‘demonised by TV nutritionists and is a vital part of our daily diet‘” screamed the Daily Mail headline on Friday 14th September.

I was pretty disgusted by this on a number of levels:

1) Conflict of interest

The article talked about nutrition scientists and then went on to explain that by this they meant people working for the British Nutrition Foundation (BNF). They even called them “Researchers at the British Nutrition Foundation” and this was a quotation from the article: “Researchers at the British Nutrition Foundation said that people are instead going without vital vitamins and minerals that are contained in each loaf.”

Here are the sustaining members of the British Nutrition Foundation. Check out Coca-Cola, Danone, Sainsbury, Kellogg’s, Kraft foods, Nestlé, PepsiCo, Tate & Lyle, The ABF Grocery Group and Unilever. The Associated British Foods (ABF) member alone is the conglomerate behind Allingson breads, Kingsmill breads, Speedibake bakery products, Sunblest breads, Burgen breads and Tip Top breads and baked goods. Kraft and Sainsbury’s will similarly welcome any support for bread – as will Unilever, as their sales of hydrogenated, bleached, deodorised and emulsified gunge – also known as margarine or spreads – needs to go on bread.

Einstein famously said that “It isn’t research if you know what you’re looking for.” I do not accept that the conflicted BNF would bite the many, many hands that feed them and therefore they will undertake ‘research’ into bread with the clear goal that it must be eulogised as an outcome.

Those were just the sustaining members. The BNF also has even more just plain members. These include the major supermarkets that benefit from selling bread: ASDA; Marks and Spencer; Morrison’s; The Co-operative Group and Waitrose. Then we have bread makers: General Mills (Pillsbury dough); Kerry Foods (Homepride); and Warburton’s. We have the bread retailer Greggs – is there anything in Greggs that is not made from flour? Just as we had Tate & Lyle (sugar) as a sustaining member, so we have British Sugar as a member – have you ever tried to buy a loaf of bread that does not contain sugar? United Biscuits are also a BNF member, as is The National Starch company. Finally, you may not even recognise Nabim as a member. Nabim, as their web site proudly states: “is the representative organisation for the UK flour millers and represents virtually 100% of the industry, which uses around 5.1 million tonnes of wheat a year to produce 4.1 million tonnes of flour.”

That’s the scale of the financial alliances held by the BNF, which need to be protected from naughty (TV) nutritionists advising people to avoid bread.

The ‘research’ should have openly and clearly declared this conflict of interest – as the ‘researchers’ would have to have done had this been published in a journal. No such declarations were even mentioned.

2) Adding vitamins & minerals does not make a fake food healthy

Back to the absurd quotation from the ‘researchers': “Researchers at the British Nutrition Foundation said that people are instead going without vital vitamins and minerals that are contained in each loaf.”

Warburton’s is the biggest bread brand in the UK and, conveniently, a member of the British Nutrition Foundation. Revenues are in excess of £700 million – mouth watering levels.

If you check Tesco on line shopping, Warburton’s has nine white bread variants and four brown bread variants available. Normally virtually the only nutrients in processed bread are vitamins and minerals that have been added in by the manufacturers. Interestingly there is no sign on the ingredients list that Warburton’s have even bothered to add any nutrients to their white bread ranges. Here’s an example, which has the ingredients Wheat Flour, Water, Yeast, Vegetable Oil, Salt, Flavouring, Soya Flour, Preservative Calcium Propionate (added to inhibit mould growth), Emulsifiers E471, E481, Flour Treatment Agents Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C),  E920. Vitamin C looks to have been the only vitamin added, which means that the white bread will have the nutritional content of its main ingredient – white flour – which is negligible – see below.

Warburton’s brown bread also has no evidence of added nutrients. This has a very similar ingredients list with wholemeal flour in place of white flour and dextrose (sugar) in this one: Wholemeal Flour (57%), Water, Yeast, Dextrose, Vegetable Oil, Salt, Wheat Gluten, Emulsifiers E481, E472e, E471, Soya Flour, Preservative Calcium Propionate (added to inhibit mould growth), Flour Treatment Agent Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C).

Most breads in the UK do have vitamins and minerals added, but this does not mean that the product is healthy. You may as well take a vitamin/mineral tablet and save yourself the unhealthy intake of flour, sugar, vegetable oil and emulsifiers. Better still – eat real food! Steak, salmon, eggs and cheese don’t need vitamins and minerals to be added – they are found in abundance naturally in these products.

Here is a nutrient comparison between some real foods and white and brown flour – the main ingredient in the bread being defended by the BNF:

(All per 100g)

Chicken Liver

Sirloin steak

Sardines

Eggs

Flour (white)

Flour (brown)

Calories

116

154

208

143

364

364

Protein Quality

149

94

148

136

43

54

Vitamins







A (IU)

11,077

0

108

487

0

9

B1 (mg)

0.3

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.4

B2 (mg)

1.8

0.1

0.2

0.5

0

0.2

B3 (mg)

9.7

7.2

5.2

0.1

1.3

6.4

B5 (mg)

6.2

0.6

0.6

1.4

0.4

1

B6 (mg)

0.9

0.6

0.2

0.1

0

0.3

Folic Acid (mcg)

588

13

12

47

26

44

B12 (μg/mcg)

16.6

1.2

8.9

1.3

0

0

C (mg)

17.9

0

0

0

0

0

D (IU)

neg

0

272

35

0

0

E (mg)

0.7

0.3

2

1

0.1

0.8

K (μg/mcg)

0

1.2

2.6

0.3

0.3

1.9


Please note that the highest value has been highlighted for a quick glance as to the highest calorie foods (flour) and the most nutritious foods (liver and sardines).

You will notice that brown flour is slightly better than white, but neither can hold a candle to liver and sardines. I wonder why the BNF are not in the Daily Mail raving about these super foods, but perhaps a check of their member list will explain why.

Please note that the above table is comparing 100 grams of each product. Flour has over three times the calories of liver, making flour products even worse if you compare them on a calorie for calorie basis.

3) If you want to be slim and healthy – ditching bread is a great idea

Did you know that the average UK citizen is consuming 1,150 calories a day from just two ingredients – one with no nutritional value and one with so little that it is subject to fortification legislation, with a requirement to add back in nutrients removed in processing?[i] World Health Organisation data tells us that the average UK citizen consumes 38 kilograms of sugar per year.[ii] Statistics from the Flour Advisory Bureau note that UK per capita flour consumption reached 74 kilograms in 2008/9.[iii] This represents a few calories short of 1,150 per person per day from those two ingredients – when did that become a healthy balanced diet?

If anyone asked me for the top substances to remove from their diet, my number one tip would be sugar – no nutritional value whatsoever – and my second tip would be flour – virtually no nutritional value. The brilliant book Wheat Belly by Dr William Davis will also give you several reasons for avoiding wheat – from belly fat to arthritis with many other ailments in between.

Without exception, people I work with to lose weight and gain health do better without wheat. They have found wheat addictive in the past, as it is the main ingredient in biscuits, cakes, pastries, pies, pizza, pasta – things that they have craved. They come off wheat, drop pounds in days, banish bloating, overcome food cravings and report many other ailments clearing up – from Irritable Bowel Syndrome to joint and muscle aches. They lose virtually nothing nutritionally, as the facts have now shown. In fact they gain masses in terms of vitamins and minerals because – as the rare people in the UK not consuming 1,150 calories of sugar and flour daily, they are having those calories in the form of steak, salmon, cheese, vegetables, seeds and so on instead. So they lose weight and gain health. As they lose lbs, the fake food companies lose £’s – hence the need for this article.

So, don’t listen to representatives of the multimillion, if not billion, pound bakery industry, otherwise known as The British Nutrition Foundation. The facts are that bread is pointless nutritionally compared to real food and has some pretty nasty fake ingredients in the processed loaves that adorn the supermarket shelves.

If you want to eat bread – either bake your own with the highest quality, most natural whole wheat flour you can find. Add yeast, olive oil and a few sunflower seeds and that’s it. You may also be able to get a decent wheaten dense kind of loaf from a farm shop or farmers market. Give the packaged stuff a wide berth and don’t believe anything that comes from The British Nutrition Foundation.



[i] http://www.opsi.gov.uk/SI/si1998/19980141.htm.

An excellent summary is available at: http://www.sustainweb.org/realbread/flour_fortification/

[ii] http://www.whocollab.od.mah.se/expl/globalsugar.html

[iii] http://www.fabflour.co.uk/content/1/31/facts-about-bread-in-the-uk.html

Posted in Conflict, Media comments
Tags: , , , ,
8 comments on “Conflicted nutritionists defend bread
  1. avatar Darren says:

    The fake British Nutrition Foundation has been known about for a long time. Goes along the same lines as McDonald’s sponsoring sports competitions….

    The bottom line is; if you want to eat healthily cook yourself and have a balanced diet. It really is that simple. But because no big company makes money from spouting that line, it drowned out with the ‘eat my product to make you feel good/loose weight/be healthy’.

    However, the ‘real’ healthy message folk are often their own worst enemies. As an example, the table Zoe shows tries to compare ‘wet’ foods, like Chicken Liver, with flour which is dry. Of course flour is going to have many more calories as there is no water to dilute it. How many calories in Chicken Liver if you dry it? I eat bread – albeit home baked – every day, but in moderation and part of a balanced diet. And I’m 119 years old.

  2. avatar Javed says:

    Hi Zoe, very nice article. About bread, whether the same holds true for the bread we make in our homes on the oven from wheat flour. This bread, as we call “chapatti” in Urdu here in Pakistan is a thin layered hand made round bread and cooked over a round shaped steel plate, called “tawa”.

    And what should be the alternative for sugar?

    Javed

  3. avatar fiona says:

    Hi Angela,have you tried Vogel bread? Maybe it’s not like home made, but it’s free from emulsifiers, enzymes or preservatives (hence it only lasts about 4 days in the fridge). I usually eat fresh/cook from fresh, and steer clear of anything with sugar and preservatives. If I want more denser carbs than fruit or veg I’ll go for brown rice and the occasional slice of Vogel bread.

  4. avatar Angela Jackson says:

    I don’t doubt anything you say. I eat lots of fruit, veges and fresh meat/fish. However, I still haven’t come up with an alternative to bread to keep my system functioning and not develop diverticulitis from a low carb diet.

  5. avatar Mark says:

    Hi Zoe,

    Excellent blog(s). It is great the way you tabulate the numbers it really hits home the nutrient content of the different foods we eat. Your table shows the protein content in chicken liver (149) higher than sardines (148) but sardines highlighted.
    “Did you know that the average UK citizen is consuming 1,150 calories a day from just two ingredients” this is incredible….
    Keep up the great work and thanks,

    Mark

  6. avatar india leigh says:

    Really interesting article. It amazes (enrages) me to discover the ‘names’ behind these organisations who tout the idea that they are a public service.

    I’d love to share the article but your ‘share’ service is not working. Please let me know if you rectify the problem.

    Thanks

    India Leigh

    • avatar Zoë says:

      Hi India – many thanks for the tip on the ‘share’ service – both hubby and I tried it and it’s slow (it’s a third party service – not to do with our site), but it did get there in the end!
      Many thanks for trying to share anyway
      Best wishes – Zoe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*


− 2 = 5

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>