5 Responses to “Dr Aseem Malhotra rallies Jamie Oliver, Steven Gerrard, teachers & doctors to fight childhood obesity”

Comments

Read below or add a comment...

  1. avatar Dave P says:

    As an initiative it is to be applauded. BUT ! ! ! there are 2 at least competing interests. Public Health on the one hand, and Stock holders and Profit Margins on the other. A third if you include Govt taxes.

    How many well intentioned bills have been through Parliament only to be watered down to be almost useless.
    Not to mention that there will almost certainly be a point at which the Elephant in the room will be that the advice so far has been wrong. Human nature says someone will be held to account. They might try and blame Scientific Understanding and its limitations OR they may just fess up and bluff it out. But those whos profit margins will be hit wont sit and wait for it to happen will they ?

    I do applaud the initiative but think it will need to be very well organised and present its case so the general public dont get baffled by the science as so often happens.

  2. avatar PeggyC says:

    This awesome. As Dave P says, there are many obstacles. But one can’t win the battle by sitting back and deciding the obstacles are too big to overcome. One must fight the obstacles one at a time. I so wish a similar drive would take place here in the US. Unfortunately, those in our government who have pledged fight childhood obesity are mired in conventional wisdom and don’t have a prayer of winning without changing the paradigm. They have recently won a campaign to limit fat and calories in school children’s meals (no full fat milk, etc.) yet still allow sugar laden low fat flavored milks to continue to be offered (because they’re low fat and therefore healthy, you know).
    On a side note, I loved your book, Ms. Harcombe, and promote it whenever and wherever I can. It is awesome.

  3. avatar PeggyC says:

    Another note: I taught my children to cook when they were still in grade school. They’re both grown up and on their own, but they still both love to cook. They make and eat healthy, real food and we all love sharing recipes and ideas. No low fat recipes allowed! Neither has a weight problem. Except for my son’s type 1 diabetes (which he manages very well on a low carb high fat diet), both are very healthy, active adults.

  4. avatar Dave P says:

    Only today on the radio ………… the potential imposition of a “Fat Tax”in the UK, For the likes of many who have learned the difference it is essentially a tax on being healthy and if like me you are a T2 diabetic and ditched the bulk of Carbs you once ate, this is saying you may be more healthy and costing the NHS less by reducing your meds but you will still pay more to live the desired healthy lifestyle.

  5. avatar Harold Dobbs says:

    I am a physician, a diabetic on insulin, very well controlled on a very low carb diet. I frequently eat at MacDonald’s. I order a double quarter pounder with cheese no bun, or bacon ranch salad with ice tea no sugar or ice coffee no sugar and have no trouble with my blood sugar. It is not MacD’s but what people eat there that is the problem. People need to understand what it is appropriate to eat not fret about the stupid things you can get in any restaurant.

Please feel free to leave a comment. For personal diet & health questions, please visit The Harcombe Diet Club Forum.